Stream: smart
Topic: SMART Ballot Reconciliation Call: 2017-11-30
Josh Mandel (Nov 30 2017 at 16:04):
For today's 3p ET meeting we'll take notes here. Please feel free to join in the discussion. https://join.freeconferencecall.com/fhir (meeting ID: FHIR)
Key docs for our call: Ballot Themes List with prioritized issues in red at the bottom; and Ballot Summary Spreadsheet with full ballot comments + dispositions so far.
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:07):
Attendees: @Josh Mandel (leading) , @Dan Gottlieb , @Robert Scanlon , @Dylan Mahalingam , @Jeffrey Danford , Lisa Erickson, @Isaac Vetter, @Nikolai Schwertner, @Debbie Bucci, @Eric Haas, @Grahame Grieve, Clark Downum
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:09):
Topic #1: "Theme: Publication Format (103, 104, 110, 163, 179, 183)"
- Topic consists of a a handful of comments focused on the actual formatting of the specification.
Jeff - we shouldn't overly pollute the specification with inline examples.
Jeff motions and Debbie seconds. PASS 8 (for), 0 (abstain), 0 (against)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:18):
Topic #2: Links to versioned FHIR spec (71)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:18):
Eric motions, Isaac seconds. PASS 9 (for), 0 (abstain), 0 (against)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:19):
Topic #3: Separate out docs for Scopes vs. Launch Context ?(142)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:25):
Eric - supports keeping the content together
Isaac - Much of the launch context content doesn't actually apply to scope and by making the page shorter, the spec is easier to read
Isaac motions, Nikolai seconds. PASS 0 (for), 0 (abstain), 0 (against)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:26):
Topic #4: Presenting access duration details to user (207)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:30):
Jeff - it seems like a nice feature and it's not a requirement
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:31):
Eric motions, Jeff seconds: against: 0, abstain:0, for: 9 - PASS
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:34):
Topic #5: Registering a SMART App with an EHR: Dynamic Ports (206)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:44):
Isaac - shouldn't we account for mobile apps?
Josh - yes, how about we point out the exception for native apps?
Isaac, Clark - sounds great!
Grahame motions, Isaac seconds. against: 0, abstain:0, for: 11 - PASS
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:47):
Topic #6: Backend Servicves (192)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:47):
Josh - backend services is important, but not mature or widely implemented and therefore shouldn't be balloted
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:48):
Josh - the backend services spec should be matured via FHIR Connectathons, the mailing list and zulip
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:48):
Grahame - how about the spec mentions that it's something we're working on?
Josh, Isaac: okay.
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:50):
Isaac motions, Grahame seconds: against: 0, abstain:0, for: 11 - PASS
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:54):
Topic #7: Three parties, or four parties?
Josh - not sure that we understand the comment.
Grahame- perhaps he's asking about security between the user and browser -- the potential for data breach between multiple users on the same platform?
Josh - I'll reach out to commenter to clarify or join next call
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:55):
Topic #8: Scopes and Scopes (186)
Isaac Vetter (Nov 30 2017 at 20:57):
Isaac - I haven't been confused between the two meaning of "launch scope" and "in scope"
Grahame - it seems unavoidable ...
Eric motions, Jeff seconds: against: 0, abstain:0, for: 10 - PASS
Last updated: Apr 12 2022 at 19:14 UTC
